
In this episode of Creating Value Wins, Steve Denning, Hugo Lorenzo, Hunter Hastings, and Doug Kirkpatrick discuss a brutal and controversial New York Times essay by Cambridge professor Christopher Marquis arguing that business schools are unfixable and should be closed down.
Together, the panel unpacks the deep-rooted flaws of the traditional business school and consulting industrial complex, why standard MBAs rely on backward-looking case studies instead of future value creation, and how top-performing innovators like NVIDIA and Amazon do things entirely differently. Join the conversation as we explore the future of management, subjective value, and what it truly means to lead through experimentation and customer focus.
00:34 – Welcome to the Creating Value Wins podcast and introduction of the panel
00:54 – Breaking news: Cambridge Professor Christopher Marquis's controversial essay claiming business schools are unfixable
02:10 – The core issue of value creation: Why top companies like NVIDIA don't rely on MBA talent
03:14 – The historical origins of the business school model and its mathematical roots
04:18 – The gap between management theory versus management practice
06:45 – The aftermath of Marquis's article and the reality of the business school-consultancy industrial complex
10:02 – New green shoots: Venture capital academies and outside-the-university alternatives
13:06 – Successful internal change: Examples from Costco, Amazon, and Microsoft
14:32 – The flaw in Michael Porter’s Five Forces and the missing customer element
16:20 – A small exercise: What subjects should be added to traditional MBAs?
19:12 – Subjective value, entrepreneurship, and the power of experimentation
22:50 – The unholy alliance of business schools and long-term consulting dependency
29:12 – How value-creating consultancies build capability and quickly exit
31:36 – Navigating competitive advantages and markets that don't exist yet
34:36 – Starting value creation at the individual level with a contribution mindset
37:16 – Why management fashions, frameworks, and metrics often fail organizations
42:20 – Is this approach real or just PR? Proof from companies like Morning Star
44:12 – Paradigm shifts and Max Planck’s observation that "science advances one funeral at a time"
46:48 – Feature: The World’s Dumbest Management Idea
51:42 – Closing thoughts: What the future of leadership and collaboration really requires